We got an email from my MIL about a month ago preparing us for the fact that they were trimming down on presents (because of the economy and they've lost 1/2 their retirement in the down market blah, blah, blah) and plan to spend only $25-$50 per family this year. Which is totally fine with me however I wanted to point out they've never spent more than $50 on us ever. Even though last year his mom decided that the kids should buy his dad a new recliner. Last year when his mom asked what we wanted I told her that we were very fortunate and just happy to have a healthy child so what we'd really like is if they made a donation to a charity of our choice. And she didn't do it. She sent us a target gift card. This year one of my husband's sisters decided that since their dad is so hard to buy for and never wants anything, she would make a donation in his name. So the MIL included that in the email and that it was a "great idea." And the rest of us could do that too. OR we could buy them a gift card to a casino or to the stores she likes. So yeah, guess what she really wants. Let me tell you a little story about her and then figure out what I decided to do for her present.
A few years ago her brother was struck and killed while crossing the street. The driver was found to be somewhat at fault - she wasn't drunk but I think she was speeding though not excessively so. So she and her siblings sued the driver (or really, the driver's insurance company) and got a settlement. Now the brother who was killed was a priest so he left behind no family of his own that needed to be provided for. I think the fact that they sued is ridiculous but since they did perhaps they should use that settlement money to do something to honor her brother - give it to his church maybe. Oh no. My MIL buys herself a new washer and dryer and fridge.
This year I'm imposing forced charity on her, I don't care if she wants a casino gift card that's a complete waste of money and I'm not going to be a part of it. She can go wrestle those nickels for the slots out of the hands of the children at St. Jude's Research Hospital if that's what she'd rather have.